The Danish Girl v Man Into Woman

I wanted to write a post comparing the recent film release The Danish Girl with the book written by Niels Hoyer, Man Into Woman, which contains diary entries and letters from Lili Elbe herself, and stories of her life written by her friend. They are in very few ways similar.

Screenshot 2015-12-31 17.20.07.png

Einar does not describe ever being told that he was schizophrenic.

Screenshot 2015-12-31 16.46.21.png

He does not record ever having to flee to avoid institutionalisation or being forced to undergo any treatment.

Screenshot 2015-12-31 17.14.53.png

As there were in fact shrunken ovaries inside Einar, that makes him intersex, and I’m not sure whether that means he is a transexual as advertised – he didn’t feel like he was in the wrong body, but that there were two persons inside his body instead, and that the female hormones began to dominate. Einar is shown going into a library and looking at a book which depicts the sexual organs of an intersex person, but there are no words to explain what he is examining, and after the twenty seconds in the library it is never referred to again. For a film that has been advertising in interviews that it is representative of the transgender community but has never once mentioned the intersex community, it concerns me that these people did not actually read the real diary of Lili Elbe, and are unknowingly portraying her falsely. Then again, if they did read it, then why are they ignoring the inter-sex community? And why were they ok with the incredible changes made in this film?

Screenshot 2015-12-31 15.12.07.png

In the film, the man that Lili meets up with several times and kisses, is a man who in the book makes an unwelcome advance and is then punched in the face by Lili, never to be seen again.

Screenshot 2015-12-31 17.18.35.png

Gerda does not marry Hans the childhood friend of Einar’s, and Einar never describes having kissed him as children. In the biography, it is in fact a childhood friend (possibly this Hans) that proposes to Lili before her final operation. If, then, the film is portraying that Lili’s near-death fiancé in fact married Gerda, then this is a seriously strange edition!

Screenshot 2015-12-31 17.16.14.png

Whilst it is true that the transgender community has been targeted with violence on many, many occasions, it is not true that Lili ever recorded being physically attacked. Also, nobody even called her names in the street. Lili was suffering emotionally because of her own mental turmoil, but not because of anyone else’s deliberate hurting of her. Overall, then, this film is so loosely inspired that I think it could really be an offence to the memory of Lili and Gerda.

And for the record, Lili comes off as seriously homophobic in the books. As Einar, he describes only ever being attracted to women, and that being a man and kissing a man would be wrong. As Lili, the idea of being with a woman is appalling and disgusting to her. Although scientifically speaking her case may be interesting, I’m not sure she should be idolised in the LGBT community.

Advertisements
This entry was posted in Christianity. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to The Danish Girl v Man Into Woman

  1. whoever says:

    I just came across your post. You don’t seem to realize that the movie The Danish Girl was based on a novel by the same name. The novel is a fictionalized account of Einar/Lili’s life; the author never claimed it was all true. He researched Lili’s life and then spun it into a story of his own creation, changing many details. He didn’t do it deceptively—he was up front about it in interviews when the book was published.

    • I did know that actually. I wanted to write a post comparing The Danish Girl and the book written by Niels Hoyer, Man Into Woman, as I stated at the start of this post. I don’t necessarily hold it against the author of The Danish Girl to use it as a source of inspiration and make many changes, but my problem was that the film which became highly popularised for a time was partly successful because the actors/actresses and the director continued to describe it as the actual Lili’s life, which it was absolutely not. I wanted to write about the massive changes to make this clear to anyone searching for a comparison.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s